Beautiful old boat! Fantastic experience to see New York from the water and get some history. I read in the reviews prior to my booking that people talked which made it difficult to hear the speaker. Unfortunately this happened on my trip too. Despite being repeatedly shooshed they continued and so I missed a lot of information. Such a shame. Was still a great experience even though it was a rainy day. Not enough food though. We were told by the speaker that there was plenty of food so not to rush. But then there was none left! I advised the staff (the girl was a bit rude not being apologetic at all); thr young guy did well to perform a ‘loaves and fishes’ miracle but still not really enough to choose from. Great concept but just needs some fine tuning.

We had a spectacular time. From the moment we boarded the beautiful Manhattan II vessel. The boat was sparkling, clean and comfortable. The staff were friendly and accommodating. The cruise was very special. The fact that we had perfect weather was great but I could see enjoying the trip even in the winter. Providing the appetizer tables with substantial snacks was a added surprise and we appreciated it. Our guide was the best - he was knowledgeable and kept us informed without being intrusive. I am a native NYer who relocated many years ago and my companions are Californians. This cruise is for EVERYONE. I haven't stopped talking about it and recommending it. I/will be back.

A group from Argentina talked in loud voices the whole time, so it was difficult to hear the commentary. I had to shush them numerous times which had no impact on their rudeness. Finally someone from the crew spoke to them, but that too was ineffective. The group’s behavior really spoiled the trip for us which we had been anticipating for quite some time.